Laser Engraver
20W vs. 50W Fiber Laser: Which Power is Ideal for Engraving Granite Monuments?
2025-12-06 11:20:36 technical college
Selecting the correct laser power for granite monument engraving is a critical decision that directly impacts your production capability, engraving quality, and business economics. Here’s a detailed, practical comparison between 20W and 50W fiber lasers for this specific application.

Core Verdict: The 50W Fiber Laser is the Professional Choice

For dedicated granite monument work, a 50W laser is the clear and strongly recommended minimum starting point. A 20W laser, while capable, is better suited for different applications.
Here is a direct performance comparison:
Feature
20W Fiber Laser
50W Fiber Laser
Winner & Why
Primary Use Case
Light surface marking, small decorative pieces, personalization on pre-polished monuments.
Professional deep engraving, full monument text & graphics, production work.
50W. It is purpose-built for the demands of the monument industry.
Engraving Depth
Very shallow (typically < 0.3mm). Creates a surface contrast mark.
Deep, tactile engraving (0.5mm - 1.5mm+). Achieves the traditional "cut" look.
50W. Depth is crucial for durability and the classic monument aesthetic.
Speed on Black Granite
Slow. Requires multiple, slow passes to achieve even a moderate contrast.
3-5x Faster. Can achieve deep marks in fewer passes at higher speeds.
50W. Drastically improves throughput and productivity.
Finish & Clarity
Can appear "grainy" or light if pushed for depth. Best for fine details.
Crisp, white, opaque finish. Excellent contrast and legibility from a distance.
50W. Provides the high-contrast, professional result clients expect.
Material Flexibility
Limited to granite; struggles with harder stones or deep work.
Handles all monument stones​ (black & gray granite, marble, some basalts) effectively.
50W. Offers greater business versatility.
Business Impact
Hobbyist or very low-volume supplemental tool.
Viable for a commercial monument shop.​ Enables profitable production.
50W. It is a revenue-generating tool, not a limiter.

Detailed Breakdown: When Might You Considera 20W Laser?

While not ideal for core monument production, a 20W laser has niche scenarios:
  1. Personalization Only:​ Adding dates, names, or small emblems to already-polished, finished monuments​ where the deep carving is done by a sandblaster or a more powerful laser. It prevents repolishing the entire surface.
  2. Small, Detailed Graphics:​ For extremely intricate, artwork-like designs where minimal material removal is desired.
  3. Extreme Budget Constraint:​ For a hobbyist or a very small start-up testing the waters, with the explicit understanding that its capabilities for deep, full monument work are severely limited.
The Critical Limitation of 20W:​ To achieve any meaningful depth, it must run very slowly with many passes. This creates excessive localized heat, which can lead to micro-fractures in the granite, a burnt appearance, and overall poor finish quality. It is an inefficient process for deep engraving.

Why 50W is the True Entry Point for Monument Work

A 50W fiber laser (especially a MOPA configuration) hits the sweet spot of power, speed, and cost​ for a professional shop.
  • Achieves the "Monument Look":​ It can reliably engrave to a depth of 0.8mm - 1.2mm, which is the standard for durable, legible memorials that will withstand decades of weathering. The mark is crisp, white, and opaque.
  • Economic Viability:​ The speed difference translates directly to labor cost savings and higher output. You can engrave a full monument inscription in a fraction of the time it would take a 20W machine.
  • Future-Proofing:​ A 50W laser gives you the capacity to handle 95% of incoming monument work, from small markers to large family stones, without being the bottleneck in your production.

Recommendation: Think Beyond Specs

Your choice should be guided by your business model:
  • For Monument Shops & Serious Fabricators:Invest in a 50W or higher (80W-100W is even better for pure production) fiber laser.​ It is a core tool that will pay for itself. Consider the 50W as the minimumprofessional standard.
  • For Hobbyists or Artists Doing Light Work:​ If you are occasionally engraving small granite tiles or personalizing small items, a 20W canwork, but manage your expectations regarding depth and speed. Be prepared for a much longer learning curve to optimize parameters.
Final Advice:​ Before purchasing, demand a material test.​ Provide the supplier with a sample of your standard black granite and ask them to run the exact job you do—full-depth text and graphics. Compare the quality, depth, and time required​ between a 20W and a 50W machine. The difference will be immediately apparent and will make the decision clear. For professional monument engraving, the 50W laser is not just an upgrade; it's the essential, correct tool for the job.
Hot keywords
Contact us